Copycat Blue Bell Peppermint Ice Cream Recipe

There’s something unforgettable about the first spoonful of Blue Bell Peppermint Ice Cream, that cool burst of mint and the sweet crunch of candy pieces that instantly feels like winter in a bowl. 

What is Blue Bell Peppermint Ice Cream?

Blue Bell peppermint ice cream is a flavor produced by Blue Bell, featuring a refreshing peppermint base enriched with bits of peppermint candy for a delightful crunch.

Ingredients:

For The Ice Cream Base:

• 2 cups heavy cream: results in a luxurious, velvety texture.
• 1 cup whole milk: balances and smooths the consistency.
• ¾ cup granulated sugar: sweetens and enhances the mint flavor.
• ⅛ teaspoon salt: enriches the overall taste.
• 4 large egg yolks: thickens the custard, adding creaminess.
• 1 teaspoon pure peppermint extract: delivers that signature minty freshness.
• 2–3 drops red food coloring (optional): achieves the iconic pink hue.

For The Mix-Ins:

• ½ cup crushed peppermint candies or candy canes: adds a delightful crunch and extra peppermint sparkle.
• Optional: ¼ teaspoon vanilla extract: lightly softens the mint flavor and adds warmth.

Instructions:

Prepare The Custard Base:

1. In a medium saucepan, combine the heavy cream, milk, sugar, and salt over medium heat. Stir gently until the sugar dissolves, ensuring the mixture is warm but not boiling.
2. In a separate bowl, whisk the egg yolks until smooth.
3. Gradually ladle about ½ cup of the warm cream mixture into the yolks while whisking. This helps temper the eggs and prevents curdling.
4. Pour the tempered yolk mixture back into the saucepan and return to medium-low heat.
5. Continuously stir with a wooden spoon or spatula until the custard thickens enough to coat the back of the spoon, around 5–7 minutes.

Add Flavor And Chill:

1. Remove from heat and mix in the peppermint extract and vanilla extract (if using).
2. Add a few drops of red food coloring for that signature peppermint pink.
3. Strain the custard through a fine-mesh sieve into a clean bowl to exclude any cooked bits.
4. Cover the bowl with plastic wrap, pressing it right onto the surface to prevent a skin from forming.
5. Chill in the refrigerator for at least 4 hours, or until completely cold. Overnight works beautifully.

Churn The Ice Cream:

1. When the base is cold, pour it into your ice cream maker and churn according to the manufacturer’s instructions (typically 20–25 minutes).
2. Once the ice cream achieves a soft-serve consistency, gently fold in the crushed peppermint candies using a spatula.

Freeze And Set:

1. Transfer the mixture into a freezer-safe container, smoothing the top evenly.
2. Cover tightly and freeze for 4–6 hours, or until firm enough to scoop.

Tips For Perfect Blue Bell Peppermint Ice Cream:

• Crush candies carefully: Place peppermint candies or candy canes in a sealed bag and gently tap with a rolling pin. Aim for small bits, not powder.
• Select quality peppermint extract: It makes a significant difference in the freshness and flavor depth.
• Chill thoroughly before churning: The colder the base, the creamier the outcome.
• Avoid overmixing the candies: Fold them in delicately so the red stripes don’t bleed too much into the cream.
• For a softer scoop: Allow the ice cream to sit at room temperature for about 5 minutes prior to serving.

What To Serve Blue Bell Peppermint Ice Cream With

Chocolate Desserts:

• Fudgy Brownies: Serve a scoop of Blue Bell peppermint Ice Cream atop warm brownies for a melted minty chocolate swirl.
• Chocolate Lava Cake: The molten center beautifully complements the crisp peppermint candy pieces, creating an indulgent dessert.
• Chocolate Cookie Sandwiches: Put a scoop of Blue Bell peppermint Ice Cream between two chewy chocolate cookies, gently press, and freeze briefly before serving.

Holiday Cookies:

• Sugar Cookies: Their buttery sweetness allows the peppermint flavor to shine. Cut them into snowflake shapes for seasonal flair.
• Gingerbread Cookies: The spices of ginger, cinnamon, and molasses harmonize beautifully with the minty tones.
• Shortbread Cookies: The crumbly texture of shortbread adds richness, making each bite melt in your mouth when paired with the ice cream.

Hot Drinks:

• Hot Chocolate: Add a small scoop into a mug for a minty mocha delight. The ice cream melts slowly, blending into a creamy mint cocoa.
• Coffee or Espresso: Serve a scoop atop freshly brewed coffee for a refreshing twist on affogato. The peppermint flavor brightens the bitterness of the espresso.
• Chai Latte: The warm spices of cardamom, cinnamon, and cloves create a cozy pairing with the minty coolness of the ice cream.

Cakes And Pastries:

• Vanilla or White Cake: The simplicity of a light sponge allows the peppermint flavor to be the focal point.
• Red Velvet Cake: The subtle cocoa in red velvet pairs perfectly with peppermint, adding a striking color contrast on the plate.
• Chocolate Yule Log (Bûche de Noël): A luxurious, nostalgic pairing, perfect for festive gatherings.

Fresh And Simple Pairings:

• Crushed Peppermint or Candy Canes: Enhance crunch and color.
• Fresh Berries: Strawberries or raspberries provide brightness and a gentle tartness.
• Whipped Cream: An airy topping that complements the richness of the ice cream without overwhelming it.
• Mini Marshmallows: Perfect for a fun, child-friendly dessert presentation.

Substitute Ingredients:

Dairy Substitutes

Heavy Cream:

• 1 cup whole milk + 2 tablespoons melted unsalted butter: replaces 1 cup of heavy cream while maintaining creaminess in the base.
• Coconut cream: works wonderfully, adding a tropical smoothness that blends beautifully with peppermint.

Whole Milk:

• 2% milk can create a lighter texture with good flavor.
• Non-dairy options: almond milk, oat milk, or soy milk yield smooth results, though oat milk tends to provide the best body in ice cream recipes.
• Tip: For plant-based milk, include 1 tablespoon of cornstarch in the custard step to aid thickness and mimic creaminess.

Sugar Substitutes:

• Coconut sugar: adds a hint of caramel flavor, enhancing the ice cream’s depth.
• Honey or maple syrup: for natural sweetness, substitute the sugar with ½ cup of liquid sweetener for every ¾ cup of sugar, reducing the milk slightly to balance the liquid content.
• Stevia or erythritol: for a low-sugar variation, these can replace granulated sugar; follow the conversion ratios provided on their packaging.

Egg Yolks (Custard Thickener):

• Cornstarch (2 tablespoons): mixed into warm milk helps thicken the mixture.
• Cream cheese (2 ounces): blended into the chilled base improves creaminess and structure.
• A touch of xanthan gum (⅛ teaspoon): stabilizes the mix and prevents iciness, especially in dairy-free recipes.

Peppermint Flavor Substitutes:

• Mint Extract: if peppermint extract is unavailable, regular mint extract can be used, though it offers a softer herbal profile.
• Crushed Candy Canes: rich in peppermint oil; use extra crushed candy and let it infuse in the warm custard for 10 minutes before straining.
• Fresh Mint Leaves: for a more natural alternative, steep ½ cup fresh mint leaves in the warm milk and cream mixture for 20 minutes, then strain before cooling. This offers a subtle yet aromatic flavor.

Food Coloring Alternatives:

• Beet juice or powder: provides a natural color without altering flavor—use a few drops of juice or ½ teaspoon of beet powder for a lovely tint.
• Strawberry purée: adds a soft pink tint along with a hint of sweetness; use sparingly to avoid overpowering the peppermint.
• Pomegranate juice: a few teaspoons can lend both color and a slight tang.

Peppermint Candy Substitutes:

• Crushed candy canes and starlight mints are excellent alternatives.
• Mini peppermint patties or white chocolate chips create a creamy texture and a fun dimension.
• Homemade peppermint bark (white chocolate layered with crushed candy canes) can be chopped and added before freezing.

Optional Add-Ins:

• Mini marshmallows: for a peppermint s’mores vibe.
• Crumbled chocolate cookies: to emulate mint cookie crunch ice cream.
• Crushed graham crackers: adding warmth and texture.
• Drizzled white or dark chocolate: for visual appeal and richness.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make this ice cream without an ice cream maker?

Yes! If you don’t have an ice cream maker, pour the chilled custard into a shallow dish and freeze it. Stir every 30 minutes for the first few hours to incorporate air and prevent ice crystals, until it’s fully frozen.

How long will the ice cream last in the freezer?

When properly stored in an airtight container, Blue Bell peppermint ice cream can last for about 1 to 2 months in the freezer. For the best texture, try to consume it within the first month.

Can I use low-fat milk instead of whole milk?

Yes, you can use low-fat milk, but keep in mind it may result in a slightly less creamy texture. Whole milk contributes to the richness of the ice cream, so it’s worth considering for the best flavor.

What can I do if my ice cream is too hard after freezing?

If your ice cream is too hard to scoop, let it sit at room temperature for about 5-10 minutes before serving. This will soften it enough to make scooping easier.

Can I add additional mix-ins to the ice cream?

Absolutely! You can customize your ice cream with various mix-ins, such as chocolate chips, nuts, or even cookie chunks. Just make sure to fold them in gently once the ice cream reaches soft-serve consistency.

Is there a non-dairy option for this recipe?

Certainly! To create a non-dairy version, use coconut cream in place of heavy cream, almond or oat milk instead of whole milk, and a suitable egg substitute like silken tofu or cornstarch for thickening. This will achieve a creamy consistency without dairy.

Final Thoughts

There’s something timeless about a bowl of Blue Bell Peppermint Ice Cream. Every spoonful feels like the sparkle of winter lights, the hum of carols, and the comfort of gathering around the table with people you love. 

More Recipes:

• Homemade Kelsen Butter Cookies Recipes
• Copycat Brown Sugar Butter Sweet Potatoes Recipe
• Copycat Crumbl Martha Stewart Chocolate Chip Cookies Recipe
• Copycat Taco Bell Mountain Dew Baja Blast Pie Recipe
• Copycat Taco Bell Flamin’ Hot Grilled Cheese Burrito Recipe