Copycat Publix Banana Pudding Ice Cream Recipe

13

Creating a homemade version of Publix Banana Pudding Ice Cream feels like welcoming a familiar friend into your kitchen. Each step becomes an opportunity to stir in your own memories, your own rhythm, your own love for desserts that speak to the soul. 

What is Publix Banana Pudding Ice Cream?

The product in question is Publix Rich & Creamy Southern Banana Pudding Ice Cream, which is a store-brand ice cream from the grocery chain Publix. 

Ingredients: 

For The Ice Cream Base (Custard Style):

• 2 cups heavy cream
• 1 cup whole milk
• ¾ cup granulated sugar
• 4 large egg yolks
• 1 ½ teaspoons pure vanilla extract
• ¼ teaspoon fine salt

For The Banana Swirl:

• 3 ripe bananas, mashed until silky
• 2 tablespoons brown sugar
• 1 tablespoon butter
• ½ teaspoon vanilla extract

Mix-Ins:

• 1 ½ cups vanilla wafer cookies, broken into small chunks
• Optional: ½ banana sliced thinly and frozen ahead of time to fold in for extra flavor.

Instructions:

Prepare The Custard Base:

1. Warm the heavy cream and whole milk in a medium saucepan over medium heat. Add the sugar and stir until it melts into the warm mixture. In a separate bowl, whisk the egg yolks until they become thick and smooth. Scoop a small amount of the warm cream mixture and slowly pour it into the yolks while whisking to keep them silky. Pour the warmed yolks back into the saucepan.
2. Keep the heat gentle and stir continuously with a wooden spoon. When the custard thickens enough to coat the back of the spoon, remove it from the stove. Stir in the vanilla extract and salt. Pour the custard through a fine mesh strainer into a clean bowl to keep the texture luxurious. Refrigerate for several hours until cold.

1. Prepare the Banana Swirl: Place the mashed bananas, brown sugar, and butter in a small skillet over medium heat. Stir until everything melds into a smooth, fragrant mixture. Add the vanilla extract and let the swirl cool completely. This step fills the ice cream with a deep banana flavor that feels warm and nostalgic.

Freeze The Ice Cream:

1. Pour the chilled custard base into your ice cream maker and churn according to the machine’s instructions. When the mixture reaches a soft-serve consistency, spoon in the banana swirl a little at a time. Add the vanilla wafer chunks and allow the machine to fold them in gently.
2. Transfer the mixture to a lidded container. Use a spoon to create ribbons of banana swirl throughout the container as you fill it, giving each scoop beautiful pockets of flavor. Freeze until firm.

Tips For The Best Publix Banana Pudding Ice Cream:

• Choose Bananas at Peak Ripeness: Ripe bananas with speckled peels give the ice cream a deeper, sweeter flavor. Their natural sugars create a comforting aroma that makes the final result more satisfying.
• Chill Every Component: Cold custard churns into a smoother texture. A chilled banana swirl also prevents melting or separating while mixing.
• Keep the Cookie Chunks Crisp: Fold the wafer cookies in at the very end of churning. Their texture stays more intact this way, adding gentle crunch and that unmistakable banana pudding feel.
• Use a Shallow Freezer Container: A wide, shallow container freezes the ice cream more evenly. It also makes scooping easier and keeps the texture velvety.
• Serve with a Personal Touch: A drizzle of caramel, a sprinkle of crushed wafers, or a few slices of frozen banana create a bowl that feels beautifully homemade and comforting.

What To Serve Publix Banana Pudding Ice Cream With

• Warm Homemade Banana Bread: A slice of warm banana bread brings out the fruitiness of the Publix Banana Pudding Ice Cream in a way that feels cozy and inviting. The bread’s soft crumb acts like a pillow for each scoop, creating a dessert that feels layered and deeply satisfying. Serve the ice cream on top of the warm slice and let it melt slowly into the bread for a silky, indulgent finish.
• Freshly Baked Vanilla Wafers: Vanilla wafers already appear inside thePublix Banana Pudding Ice Cream, so pairing them with crisp, freshly baked wafers adds a wonderful echo of texture. A handful on the side creates a playful dipping experience. Crushing a few over the top adds fragrance and crunch that feels nostalgic and homey.
• Caramel-Drizzled Pound Cake: Thick slices of pound cake pair beautifully with banana flavors. A drizzle of caramel on the cake deepens the sweetness and warms the dessert. Place a scoop of the Publix Banana Pudding Ice Cream on top, and you have a dessert that feels smooth, elegant, and deeply flavorful.
• Cinnamon-Roasted Pecans: Cinnamon brings out the cozy notes in banana and vanilla. Roasted pecans add aroma, nuttiness, and a gentle crunch. Sprinkle them on top of a bowl of ice cream or serve them in a small dish alongside it. Their warmth highlights the creamy texture in a very inviting way.
• Whipped Cream and Fresh Banana Slices: Fresh banana slices create a lovely connection with the Publix Banana Pudding Ice Cream’s swirl. A cloud of whipped cream adds softness and height to the dish. This pairing makes the dessert feel festive and full, as though it belongs at a special gathering or celebration.
• A Warm Skillet Cookie: A golden skillet cookie provides a beautiful base for a scoop of banana pudding ice cream. The warmth from the cookie melts the edges of the scoop, creating pockets of creamy banana sweetness that seep into the soft cookie center.
• Shortbread Cookies for Dipping: Shortbread has a buttery, melt-away texture that complements the creaminess of the Publix Banana Pudding Ice Cream. Every bite feels like a blend of cool, smooth banana-pudding richness and crumbly, buttery cookie goodness.
• Caramelized Bananas: Sliced bananas cooked with a bit of sugar until golden bring a deep, glossy sweetness that feels luxurious beside a cold scoop of ice cream. Spoon them over the top to create a warm-meets-cool sensation that feels soothing and flavorful.
• A Simple Fruit Bowl: A bowl of strawberries, blueberries, or peaches shines next to the banana pudding flavor. The ice cream becomes the creamy anchor while the fruit adds color and brightness to the plate.

Substitute Ingredients:

Substitutes For Heavy Cream:

• Half-and-Half + Butter: Mix 2 cups of half-and-half with 2 tablespoons of melted butter. The butter adds richness that helps the mixture freeze smoothly.
• Coconut Cream: Coconut cream brings a thick, silky body that works beautifully in custard-style ice cream. It’s natural fat content supports a smooth texture. It also adds a gentle aroma that blends well with banana.
• Evaporated Milk: Evaporated milk creates a soft, milky flavor and a lighter feel while still supporting a creamy freeze. For extra richness, pair it with whole milk or a small amount of butter.

Substitutes For Whole Milk:

• 2% Milk: This option works well in the custard while keeping it smooth and stable. A longer churn time may create an even silkier texture.
• Oat Milk: Oat milk’s natural thickness supports freezing and blends comfortably with banana flavors. Look for a full-fat version for the best result.
• Almond Milk (Thickened): Almond milk can work when paired with 1–2 tablespoons of cornstarch to create a fuller texture during cooking.

Substitutes For Egg Yolks:

• Cornstarch Slurry: Mix 2 tablespoons of cornstarch with a splash of cold milk. Add it to the warm milk mixture and heat until it thickens. This creates a smooth base with a stable consistency.
• Sweetened Condensed Milk: A half cup folded into the milk mixture creates richness and body without the need for eggs. It also adds a caramel-like sweetness that works well with banana.
• Custard Powder: A tablespoon whisked into warm milk thickens beautifully and complements banana pudding flavors.

Substitutes For Bananas in the Swirl:

• Banana Extract + Vanilla Pudding: Use prepared vanilla pudding flavored lightly with banana extract. It forms a swirl with a silky texture very similar to banana pudding desserts.
• Freeze-Dried Bananas (Rehydrated): Rehydrate freeze-dried banana pieces with warm water until soft and mashable. This creates a flavorful purée that blends easily into a swirl.
• Banana Baby Food: High-quality banana baby purée gives a smooth, clean banana flavor with a ready-to-use consistency.

Substitutes For Vanilla Wafers:

• Shortbread Cookies: Crumbly shortbread adds buttery richness that melts slightly into the ice cream, creating beautiful pockets of flavor.
• Graham Crackers: Broken graham crackers offer a sweet, comforting texture that blends naturally with the banana custard flavor.
• Butter Cookies: Butter cookies add structure and richness. Their smooth, buttery notes pair gracefully with banana.
• Sponge Cake Cubes: Small cubes of sponge or pound cake freeze well in ice cream and bring a tender, pudding-like feel.

Substitutes For Sugar:

• Brown Sugar: Brown sugar adds a warm caramel note that pairs beautifully with banana.
• Honey: Honey creates a floral sweetness and contributes to a softer mouthfeel.
• Maple Syrup: Maple syrup gives depth and comfort to the banana flavor while keeping the custard smooth.
• Coconut Sugar: Coconut sugar melts evenly into warm custard and lends a mild, earthy sweetness.

Substitutes For Butter In The Banana Swirl:

• Coconut Oil: Coconut oil melts smoothly and enhances banana flavor with a tropical aroma.
• Ghee: Ghee brings a rich, nutty fragrance that blends well with the brown sugar and banana mixture.
• Neutral Baking Oil: A mild baking oil can bind the banana swirl without overpowering the flavor.

Substitutes For Vanilla Extract:

• Vanilla Bean Paste: Vanilla bean paste offers a more intense flavor and beautiful flecks throughout the ice cream.
• Vanilla Powder: A pinch adds softness and aroma to both the custard and banana swirl.
• Almond Extract (Used Mildly): A tiny amount introduces a delicate sweetness that complements banana without overshadowing it.

Final Thoughts

The combination of the French custard-style base, those luxurious swirls of banana sauce, and the satisfying bits of vanilla wafer truly captures the spirit of a classic Southern dessert. 

More Ice Cream Recipes:

• Copycat Blue Bell Peppermint Ice Cream Recipe
• Copycat Baskin Robbins Dubai Chocolate Sundae Recipe
• Copycat Blue Bell banana pudding Ice Cream Sandwich Recipe
• Copycat Light And Fit Greek Yogurt Recipe